CFRs & Ambulance allocation in Kathmandu
DHAKAL Framework: Integrating Community First Responders and Independent Ambulances in Kathmandu Valley
Decision-support model built on van den Berg et al. (2026) · निर्णय सहयोग मोडेल
DHAKAL = Decentralized · Heuristic · Allocation · Kernel-based · Autonomous · Loss-minimizing
Question अनुसन्धान प्रश्न
How can emergency services most effectively integrate and manage independent, unpredictable capacity sources (volunteer community first responders, and independent ambulances) to improve response times and reliability?
आपतकालीन सेवाहरूले स्वतन्त्र र अनिश्चित क्षमताका स्रोतहरू (CFR स्वयंसेवक र स्वतन्त्र एम्बुलेन्स) लाई कसरी सबैभन्दा प्रभावकारी रूपमा एकीकृत र व्यवस्थापन गरी प्रतिक्रिया समय र भरपर्दोपन सुधार गर्न सक्छन्?
Answer · उत्तर
Updates live with the settings below; based on simulated Kathmandu inputs. / तलका सेटिङसँगै आफैं अद्यावधिक हुन्छ।
Scenario Setup · परिस्थिति छनोट
Time Limits You Can Edit · समय सीमा
Only whole numbers that you can count or measure in real life are shown. Area data (calls per day, CFR travel time, kits) is shown on the map in Figure 1. / क्षेत्रको तथ्याङ्क (दैनिक कल, CFR समय, किट) Figure 1 को नक्सामा देखाइएको छ।
Table 1
Time Limit to Reach the Patient, by Emergency Level
Note. Values are planning estimates; replace them with local records (ambulance logs, ward data). / स्थानीय अभिलेखले यी मान बदल्नुहोस्।
Results · नतिजा
Who Arrives First at the Selected Location · को पहिले पुग्छ?
Table 2
Arrival of Responders at the Selected Location
Figure 1
Map of Kathmandu Valley Zones Showing the Patient Location, CFR Kits, Ambulance Hubs, and the Example Responders' Arrival Times
Note. Pulsing signal = patient, coloured by emergency: red = heart attack (Level 1), yellow = asthma/breathing (Level 2), green = general illness (Level 3). Blue dashed line = ambulance from its hub; purple line = CFR volunteer. Circle size = kits placed; the number after each zone name = kits placed, and the small line above it = emergency calls per day · CFR travel minutes; colour red→green = CFR coverage; 🚑 = ambulance hubs. Click a circle to move the patient; use + / − or scroll to zoom; drag to pan. Positions are approximate. View area in Google Maps.
City-Wide Comparison of Three Management Policies · तीन नीति
Most Effective Management Lever · कुन उपाय सबैभन्दा प्रभावकारी?
Table 3
Gain in On-Time Help From a 20% Increase in Each Lever
Game Theory in Plain Words: Reward and Volunteer Response · खेल सिद्धान्त
The idea. Think of the emergency service as a manager who offers a small reward each time a volunteer answers an alert. Each volunteer then thinks: “Is the reward, plus my wish to help, worth the effort of travelling?” Volunteers living far from the patient say yes less often. The manager looks ahead at this reaction and picks the reward that gives the most on-time help for a sensible cost. If the reward is too low, volunteers ignore alerts. If it is too high, money is wasted for little extra gain.
सरल अर्थ। व्यवस्थापकले हरेक अलर्टमा सानो इनाम तोक्छ। स्वयंसेवकले “इनाम र सहयोगको चाहना यात्राको प्रयासभन्दा बढी हो?” भनेर सोच्छन्। टाढाका स्वयंसेवकले कम स्वीकार्छन्। व्यवस्थापकले यो प्रतिक्रिया अगाडि नै हेरेर कम खर्चमा सबैभन्दा बढी समयमै सहयोग पुग्ने इनाम रोज्छ। धेरै कम इनामले अलर्ट बेवास्ता हुन्छ; धेरै बढीले पैसा खेर जान्छ।
Figure 2
Share of Patients Helped on Time and Overall Score at Different Reward Levels
Interpretation · व्याख्या
Scope and Limitations · दायरा र सीमा
The model covers CFRs and independent ambulances, their random availability, commitment, and who arrives first. It does not cover hospital capacity, several emergencies at once, road-network routing, or clinical outcomes. Zones, calls, travel times, and time limits are simulated planning values, not official statistics; replace them with local data. Results shown are rounded to whole numbers and carry a small random error of about 1–2 percentage points. The words “heuristic” and “kernel-based” describe the simple placement rule and the distance-fading idea used here; they are not a full optimisation. This tool supports decisions only; in an emergency call 102 (ambulance) or 100 (police).
समेटिएको: CFR र स्वतन्त्र एम्बुलेन्स, अनिश्चित उपलब्धता, प्रतिबद्धता, को पहिले पुग्छ। नसमेटिएको: अस्पताल क्षमता, एकैसाथ धेरै घटना, सडक-सञ्जाल, क्लिनिकल नतिजा। मानहरू नमुना (सिमुलेटेड) हुन्; स्थानीय तथ्याङ्कले बदल्नुहोस्। आपतकालमा १०२ वा १०० मा फोन गर्नुहोस्।
References
van den Berg, P. L., Calmon, A. P., Gernert, A. K., Lemmens, S., Rabinovich, M., & Romero, G. (2026). The value of time and location commitment for decentralized emergency medical services. Manufacturing & Service Operations Management. https://doi.org/10.1287/msom.2025.0324